Locked candidates in Sudoku

Use it when a box confines every position for a digit to one row or column. Check the proof below, then try a different board.

PAPER ADVENTURE · WORKED EXAMPLE

Locked candidates: one justified move

Independent teaching positionOnly candidate 9 is shown in the observed group; · means this digit is excluded there. R = row; C = column.
C1C2C3C4C5C6C7C8C9
R1R2R3R4R5R6R7R8R9
1
9
7
6
1
9
3
8
·
9
9
4
·
·
7
9
9
·
4
5
6
3
7
·
·
9
2
4
7
8
3
5
1
5
6
7
Observe this groupReasoning cluen Note removed

Follow digit 9 in box 4.

R4C2
123689

Candidates before this move
1, 2, 3, 6, 8, 9. These notes are calculated from the fixed entries, not supplied as an unexplained list.

  1. Check every cell of box 4 for 9. Its only legal positions are R4C2, R4C3.

  2. All those positions lie in row 4. The box must place 9 somewhere on that row, although the order is still undecided.

  3. Remove 9 from R4C8, R4C9. Each cell is in row 4 but outside box 4. Keep the candidates inside the box.

1 / 3

The explanation stays readable at every step. Buttons change the diagram’s emphasis.

UNDERSTAND THE RULE BEFORE REUSING IT

What are locked candidates?

Locked candidates connect a box with a row or column. If every possible position for a digit inside one box lies on the same line, that box must place the digit on that line. The digit can therefore be removed from the rest of the line outside the box. This lesson teaches this pointing form of the technique.

Check these conditions

  • Check the whole 3×3 box, not only two matching notes.
  • All legal positions for the digit inside that box share one row or column.
  • There is a matching candidate on that line outside the box to remove.
CHECK EVERY POSITION

The evidence behind the move

The whole box 4 must be checked before using its alignment with row 4.

PositionWhat the board establishes
R4C1Excludes 9: R3C1 already contains 9 in the crossing column.
R4C2Allows 9: no fixed copy blocks this cell.
R4C3Allows 9: no fixed copy blocks this cell.
R5C1Excludes 9: R3C1 already contains 9 in the crossing column.
R5C2Already filled with 4; this position is occupied.
R5C3Already filled with 5; this position is occupied.
R6C1Already filled with 7; this position is occupied.
R6C2Excludes 9: R6C6 already contains 9 in the crossing row.
R6C3Excludes 9: R6C6 already contains 9 in the crossing row.
FOLLOW THE COMPLETE REASONING

Why can 9 be removed outside box 4?

box 4 can place 9 only at R4C2, R4C3, all in row 4. Wherever that box places its 9, the rest of the same row cannot contain another 9.

Why the elimination is forced

Every completed box contains one copy of each digit. If its only possible copies of a digit are on one row, the box will eventually use that digit somewhere on that row. Placing another copy elsewhere on the same row would make a repeat. The conclusion is about the outside cells; it does not decide which position inside the box will be used.

IF

R4C2 = 9

Then row 4 already has its 9. Remove 9 from R4C8, R4C9 outside the box.

IF

R4C3 = 9

Then row 4 already has its 9. Remove 9 from R4C8, R4C9 outside the box.

These are cases considered by this rule, not two completed solutions. Each case gives the same outside removals, so you can make those removals without choosing an inside position.

What pointing does not tell you

Do not fill either of the reserved positions simply because the pattern looks strong. Both remain possible. Remove only the justified candidates outside the box, then scan the affected cells for singles. A useful elimination may create no immediate placement.

What changes after the justified removals?
CellBeforeRemoveRemaining
R4C81, 991
R4C91, 5, 6, 991, 5, 6
Now check for a single

R4C8 now has only 1. Other affected cells still have several candidates; leave them unfilled. Update notes after each placement before looking for another pattern.

The related claiming form

The relationship can also be read in the other direction: if every position for a digit in a row is inside one box, remove that digit from the other cells of that box. This is often called claiming. The direction and the removal region change, so first practise the pointing example here without mixing the two rules.

Pointing and claiming use different starting groups
FormEstablish firstRemove from
Pointing — this worked exampleAll positions for one digit in a box share one line.That row or column outside the box.
Claiming — the reverse directionAll positions for one digit in a line share one box.Other cells of that box outside the line.

Check every empty cell in the box. Two aligned notes do not establish a lock if another legal position exists off that line. Keep the inside candidates. The changed-clue example below demonstrates that failure.

A SIMILAR POSITION THAT DOES NOT QUALIFY

What breaks this deduction?

Remove the fixed 9 at R3C1 from the example. The remaining entries are still consistent, but that missing constraint changes the legal candidates.

R4C1
9
R4C2
9
R4C3
9
R5C1
9

Inside box 4, 9 now has positions R4C1, R4C2, R4C3, R5C1. They no longer all lie in row 4, so that box does not justify the original outside removals.

The lesson: Two aligned candidates do not establish a lock if a third candidate exists elsewhere in the box.

Inspect the changed full board
Changed teaching positionOnly candidate 9 is shown in the observed group; · means this digit is excluded there. R = row; C = column.
C1C2C3C4C5C6C7C8C9
R1R2R3R4R5R6R7R8R9
1
9
7
6
1
3
8
9
9
9
4
·
·
7
9
9
9
4
5
6
3
7
·
·
9
2
4
7
8
3
5
1
5
6
7
Observe this groupReasoning cluen Note removed

This changed position is a counterexample to the original move, not a second puzzle you need to finish.

Sources and further practice

Technique reference

HoDoKu: pointing and claiming →

The reference explains the general rule. The boards, deductions and exercises here are our own teaching examples, separate from your game.

YOUR TURN · DIFFERENT BOARD · FREE

Try one locked candidates deduction

Review the example ↑

In box 7, 9 is confined to row 7. Select all 9 notes that this removes outside the box.

Independent teaching positionOnly candidate 9 is shown in the observed group; · means this digit is excluded there. R = row; C = column.
C1C2C3C4C5C6C7C8C9
R1R2R3R4R5R6R7R8R9
6
2
9
4
1
6
1
3
5
6
7
2
6
1
8
5
5
3
7
8
4
9
8
3
4
2
Observe this groupYour selected celln Note removed

Choose notes to remove

Select a cell on the board or use the menu. Then choose each digit to remove. Check your complete deduction when ready.

Toggle candidate removals
No deduction selected yet.

This independent exercise does not change your game, points or leaderboard result. Reset to try again.

CLEAR UP THE COMMON STICKING POINTS

Locked candidates questions

Can I remove the digit from cells outside the shared line?

Not from this pointing argument alone. The removal region is the shared row or column outside the source box; keep the candidates inside the box.

What if there is nothing outside the box to remove?

The alignment produces no candidate change in that position. Keep the inside possibilities and look for another justified move.

Must there be exactly two positions in the box?

No. Two or three positions can form a pointing pattern, provided all of them lie on the same row or column.

Does a locked-candidate move always place a digit?

No. It removes candidates. A placement follows only if the remaining notes or positions establish another valid deduction.

KEEP THE LEARNING CONNECTED

Continue with naked pair

Use it when two cells in one group each contain exactly the same two candidates.

Read the next tutorial